American Independent Business Alliance

The Multiplier Effect of Local Independent Businesses

This resource also is offered in Spanish (leer en español).  For holiday-themed versions of the multiplier effect graphs below, see this menu.

Clearly communicating the importance of the local economic multiplier effect or “local premium” is a key part of effective “buy local” and public education campaigns. The multiplier results from the fact that independent locally-owned businesses recirculate a far greater percentage of revenue locally compared to absentee-owned businesses (or locally-owned franchises*). In other words, going local creates more local wealth and jobs.

The multiplier is comprised of three elements — the direct, indirect, and induced impacts.

Local-Economic-Return-Multiplier-Graphs-01

click to enlarge or capture image

  • Direct impact is spending done by a business in the local economy to operate the business, including inventory, utilities, equipment and pay to employees.
  • Indirect impact happens as dollars the local business spent at other area businesses re-circulate.
  • Induced impact refers to the additional consumer spending that happens as employees, business owners and others spend their income in the local economy.

The private research firm Civic Economics has executed the bulk of studies attempting to quantify the difference in local economic return between local independents and chain businesses. Their first such study (pdf), for the city of Austin, Texas showed an independent bookseller (Book People) and music seller (Waterloo Records) returned more than three times as much money to the local economy as a proposed Borders Books and Music outlet would.*

Those results since have been mirrored by subsequent studies (ten summarized here), each showing a much greater local multiplier for spending at independent businesses than chains. These studies measured the direct and indirect impacts to determine the base level local economic activity of a purchase made at a chain and a local independent business.

On average, 48 percent of each purchase at local independent businesses was recirculated locally, compared to less than 14 percent of purchases at chain stores. (See blue graph)

click to enlarge or capture image

The Institute for Local Self-Reliance conducted perhaps the simplest study of the local multiplier effect in several small Maine communities in 2003. The study examined how much of a dollar spent at a local independent store is re-spent in the local area as payroll, goods/services purchased from area businesses, profits spent locally by owners, and as donations to area charities. The study found each $100 spent at local independents generated $45 of secondary local spending, compared to $14 for a big-box chain — nearly identical to later results across the many Civic Economics studies.

“Independent retailers return more than three times as much money per dollar of sales than chain competitors.”

Other studies by Civic Economics in Grand Rapids, Michigan and Chicago expanded exploration of the indirect impacts by including more business types (see discussion below) and added induced impacts, so the results are not directly comparable to most other CE studies or the ILSR Maine study. While the body of research in this realm is still small, we are unaware of any studies inconsistent with the results referenced above.

Tweet This

Key Points
Civic Economics’ Andersonville neighborhood (Chicago) study found a total impact (direct, indirect and induced) of $.68 for each dollar spent at ten local independents, compared to $.43 projected for their chain competitors. However, the projection of indirect and induced impacts does not mean $.68 of each dollar spent at a local independent “stays” in the local economy — an inaccurate claim that has been spread widely. It means $.68 of additional local economic return ultimately is generated after additional spending cycles. Citing the higher numbers without explaining they include impacts by entities other than the original business is simply wrong and can undermine the credibility of your group or campaign.

AMIBA_posterconcepts-finalBear in mind the Andersonville study examines just ten businesses in one neighborhood of one large city, so we discourage extrapolating its findings too broadly. Businesses in smaller cities and towns typically have less ability to source many goods and services locally.

To gain respect as an authoritative voice within your community, we suggest you guard your credibility by checking your materials to ensure they convey verifiable, accurately-worded information and don’t rely on secondary sources. (One major U.S. newspaper reported that 80% of money spent with local independents was re-spent locally. At least two other outlets then wrongly attributed this claim to AMIBA, which is why we’re now zealous about correcting misinformation.)

Stickiness
In addition to being accurate, make sure your message is memorable. Saying, “independent retailers return more than three times as much money per dollar of sales than chain competitors,” is a far more memorable phrase than talking in terms of percentages or comparing $.68 to $.43. For restaurants, consider framing like “locally-owned independent restaurants return twice as much to our local economy than chain restaurants per dollar of revenue.”

Of course, you could add, “and buying remotely on the web creates almost no local benefit–just a few minutes’ work for a delivery person.” You also may add for your outreach materials or interviews, “That adds up to a huge difference in creating local jobs and local wealth.” Calculating the added local wealth that would be generated by a 10% shift to local independents is one tactic successfully employed by several communities.

Details on Study Variants

multiplier-dollars

Click to enlarge. *Estimated local benefit of remote sales ($1.02) based on driver wage of $17/hr (average of multiple sources) and 15 stops/hr (Wall St Journal) of which 85% are to deliver a single item. Local return is slightly higher in cities with processing centers. Download this image as a facebook banner!

Business Type
The size of the local premium varies depending on the type of business. Restaurants and service providers generate a large multiplier because they are labor-intensive and, therefore, more of each dollar of revenue goes to local payroll. Most retailers, unless they source an exceptionally high percentage of their goods locally, also create a more modest multiplier than restaurants.

This is not to say restaurants are better for economic development than retail. May retailers have sizable revenue and professional job opportunities, which are important to any local economy. It’s just helpful to be aware of these differences because the mix of businesses involved in a particular study will influence the results.

Land Use
In 2009, Stay Local!, an AMIBA affiliate in New Orleans, commissioned Civic Economics to evaluate economic return per square foot of retail space used by both local merchants and Target Corporation. The local merchants studied generated twice as much sales activity per square foot and nearly quadrupled the local economic return per square foot compared to projections for Target. See the resulting report: Thinking Outside the Box (pdf).

 

Quantifying Shifts in Spending
To gauge the overall impact on your local economy of shifting 10% of purchasing from non-local or absentee-owned to locally-owned businesses, you would need to know the local multiplier for each category of spending and the percentage of people’s spending in each category. (i.e., 20% goes to groceries and the grocery multiplier is 0.15; 5% goes to books and the local multiplier is 0.32; etc.)

“Buying remotely creates almost no local benefit – just a few minutes’ work for a delivery person.”

Presumably, this is how Civic Economics arrived at the Grand Rapids figures for the impact of shifting 10% of all retail sales. The average local multiplier in that study works out to 0.16 across all retail categories.

Thanks to Civic Economics and Stacy Mitchell of ILSR for assistance with this content. ILSR summarizes and links many related studies on the impact of big box development. Note: AMIBA does not conduct these studies. Please contact Civic Economics for information about commissioning one for your community.

* The Austin Independent Business Alliance (one of AMIBA’s first affiliates) used the study results to rally opposition against a public subsidy planned by the City to attract a Borders Books and Music store. AIBA succeeded. Tellingly, the corporation chose not to compete on a level playing field against two well-run independents and Borders never opened. (We don’t know if the City sent AIBA a thank you note when Borders Inc. shut down a few years later.)


CIWL-rotating
A Note on Franchises. Despite claims by countless franchisors (the companies that sell to a person wishing to operate a franchise — the franchisee), franchised businesses overall are no more likely to succeed than independent businesses and typically deliver a worse return on investment, (see the links at bottom of this page for documentation). The local multiplier effect of most franchises will fall between that of local independents and chain competitors in their business category.

Multiplier Effect Studies (all links are pdfs)

Independent We Stand/National Retail Hardware Assoc., spring, 2015. Specific to home improvement retail.

Monadnock Region, NH, fall 2014

Hudson Valley, NY, spring 2014

British Columbia 2013 (see p. 12)

Albuquerque, NM 2013

 

AMIBA Pages Of Related Interest

Keys to Effective Buy Local Campaigns

Studies and Research Sources on Impacts of Big Box Retail

Top Reasons to Buy Local, Eat Local, Go Local

Tags: , ,

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Focus on DIY Economy and Take Action on SB 197 « CAMEO - […] a related note, the American Independent Business Alliance has posted an excellent article on the multiplier effect of locally…
  2. Billions of pounds of cheese are about to go to garbage. Clearly America requires your help. | - […] is all great for the cheese customer and the local economy. But not so much for the…
  3. Lower Taxes On Ontario’s Real Job Creators — Small Businesses | Updates By James - […] community benefit as well. Studies have shown that locally owned, independent businesses spend three times more money to support…
  4. Lower Taxes On Ontario’s Real Job Creators — Small Businesses – Today's News - […] community benefit as well. Studies have shown that locally owned, independent businesses spend three times more money to support…
  5. Benefits of Shopping Locally – Heads & Tails - […] the community – buying supplies, advertising, using local contractors, and much more. In fact, one study found that for…
  6. Boston has a grocery market you’ll be jealous of, and it’s not owned by a giant corporation. – Pinot Gear - […] Did you understand that for each $100 invested at a locally-owned company, $48 of that gets recycle…?…
  7. Another Reason To Buy Local Produce - World Big News - […] buying locally carries obvious economic benefits — and some studies have explored these effects – the recent news about local food comes from the…
  8. The Top 50 Small Business Marketing and Customer Loyalty Advice Articles of 2016 - Marketing Tips | City Marketing - […] the backbone of our communities. And, that makes local businesses more important than ever. How so? According to Civic…
  9. If Not Artisanal, At Least Locally Owned – Anthony Battiato - […] that money spent locally with remain local. The American Independent Business Alliance says that $.48 of each dollar spent…
  10. About – Watda - […] spends his money locally, significant amount of that money stays in the community. In fact, one Chicago study found that for…
  11. Chris Fowler for Syracuse Mayor | Syracuse, New York - […] Fowler said that local businesses return more income into the local economy compared than chain retailers. On average, chain…
  12. The Vital Role Small Town Businesses | SharedTEAMS - […] study found on the American Independent Business Alliance said that independent retailers returned more […]
  13. 10 Great Things that Happen when you Spend your Money Locally – Kindness In Demand - […] study found that for every $100 spent locally, on average $45 stayed in the community. Meaning that there […]
  14. Why Local is Better for Businesses and Institutions – Make/Grow Local - […] their money back into the local economy. As a result, the area is economically enriched. The American Independent Business…
  15. My favorite Nashville Back to School shopping spots - Nashville Real Estate - Gabriela Lira - […] the local level and is owned by local owners, The American Independent Business Alliance shares how something significant happens with…
  16. The Vital Role Small Town Businesses Play in Communities | SharedTEAMS - […] study found on the American Independent Business Alliance said that independent retailers returned more […]
  17. What Happens When You Buy Local? - Howard Packaging - […] is called the Multiplier Effect, and according to the American Independent Business Alliance, The multiplier is comprised of three…
  18. Tatiana Castro - […] fact is that there are very direct and tangible results that come from shopping locally. In fact, a study…
  19. reasons to shop local - […] to Amiba (American Independent Business Alliance), “On average, 48 percent of each purchase at local […]
  20. The Benefits of Local Tree Removal Companies | Timber Works Tree Care - […] who are not local, and ultimately end up serving their corporate headquarters, not your local area. According to one…
  21. Switch to Solar vs. the National Installers - Switch to Solar - […] https://www.amiba.net/resources/multiplier-effect/ […]
  22. How One City in Spain Launched a Local Currency – Enjeux énergies et environnement - […] currency projects like the grama seek to increase the “local money multiplier effect.” The idea is that communities can increase…
  23. How Money Stays in Your Community When You Buy Local - Howard Packaging - […] is called the Multiplier Effect, and according to the American Independent Business Alliance, The multiplier is comprised of three…
  24. The Advantages of Renting Furniture from a Small Business – Fashion Furniture Rental - […] by supporting a small, family business. More of your money will stay in your community when you do; research…
  25. Why You Should Spend Your Money Right Here in Leeds - Pratt's Information Store - […] Local businesses select and purchase materials from other local or nearby businesses, and develop relationships over long periods of…
  26. Three Important Words That Don't Make Craft Beer Taste Better - The Great Strategery - […] Buying from a local, small, independent craft brewery makes a huge difference. […]
  27. Chris Fowler, 8th mayoral candidate, plans to reinvigorate Syracuse | The Daily Orange – The Independent Student Newspaper of Syracuse, New York - […] Fowler said that local businesses return more income into the local economy compared than chain retailers. On average, chain…
  28. Thank You Milwaukee Brides & Grooms! - MarriedinMilwaukee.com - […] you know that when spending money locally, 48% of each purchase is recirculated locally, compared to less than 14%…
  29. The Top 50 Small Business Marketing and Customer Loyalty Advice Articles of 2016 | FiveStars INSIGHTS - […] the backbone of our communities. And, that makes local businesses more important than ever. How so? According to Civic…
  30. Evelyn Durden – MyXXfly - […] business owners are more invested in improving the community in which they operate, in fact, studies show that for…
  31. Local vs. Organic: Which is Best? - Institute for Responsible Technology - […] is good for local and regional economies keeping .48c of each $1 spent in the local economy when buying…
  32. The Vital Role Small Town Businesses Play in Communities - […] study found on the American Independent Business Alliance said that independent retailers returned more […]
  33. Shop Local to Finish Checking off Your Christmas Lists - […] spent at neighborhood businesses also affect the local economy directly. Due to the multiplier effect, close to half of…
  34. Shop Local, Shop Colorado - The DimeThe Dime - […] by the American Independent Business Alliance (AIBA) on “The Multiplier Effect of Local Businesses” conducted in recent years have…
  35. Hearsay | 6 reasons to shop small this holiday season - […] convinced? Per Civic Economics, “on average, 48% of each purchase at local independent businesses is recirculated locally, […]
  36. Small Business Saturday and Supporting Female Entrpreneurs - […] average, 48 percent of each purchase at local independent business is recirculated locally, compared to less than 14 percent…
  37. Skip Black Friday: Why Small Business Saturday Is The New Tradition | The Loyal Locals Blog - […] at a big chain and your money just disappears from the community you live in and love. Actually, 3…
  38. Monthly Handmade Style Guide- Small Business Saturday – Dramatique Designs - […] businesses bring economic advantages; when you buy local more money stays within the community. One Chicago study found that…
  39. 6 Reasons to Support Small Businesses this Holiday Season - Cause You Care – Shop for a Cause - […] invested in a small business tends to remain local. An estimated $48 of every $100 stays in the local…
  40. How Shopping with a Small Business Owner Is Good for You - Norwex Movement - […] AMIBA: The Multiplier Effect of Local Independent Businesses […]
  41. Boston has a grocery marketplace you'll be jealous of, and it's not owned by a giant corporation. - Simon Weiner's Making Money Blog - […] Did you know that for every $100 expend at a locally-owned business, $48 of that get recycled right ……
  42. What restaurant franchises and chains work in small towns? - […] a look at the research. Independent restaurants generate twice as much local economic impact as chain restaurants. (Have you…
  43. The Benefits of Supporting the Maker Movement | - […] Based on a study by AmIBA, for every dollar spent on local business in a Chicago neighborhood, “$0.68 cents…
  44. Bank Local! – Flagstaff Independent Business Alliance - […] Build wealth locally instead of exporting it to Wall St. […]
  45. Looking After Local Enterprise and Life (Part I) | Chris Perley's Blog - […] https://www.amiba.net/resources/multiplier-effect/ […]
  46. » Strength in Numbers, August 2016 - […] Local Multiplier Effect […]
  47. Instead of hating the place where you live, train yourself to love it — Quartz - […] love your city, you do what’s good for it. Shopping at local independent stores kicks in the local multiplier…
  48. Local First Milwaukee Has Localization Brewing | AMIBA - […] Local Multiplier Effect […]
  49. 6 REASONS TO SUPPORT SMALL BUSINESS & SHOP LOCAL – THE BETTER WAY TO GIFT, FUN AND PERSONALIZED GIFT CARDS - […]    Infographic via Amiba […]
  50. Buying Local – Green Inc. - […] will stay in the local economy, as opposed to 13.6% when you shop at chain retailers! Thanks AMIBA), we…
  51. 7 Ways To Support Your Community – Silver-Legacy - […] to American Independent Business Association, a whopping 48% of each purchase made in your local independent businesses stays in…
  52. Portland Buy Local Keeps the Character in One of New England’s Great Cities | AMIBA - […] Local Multiplier Effect […]
  53. Portland Buy Local: 10 Years of Supporting Indie Business in Maine | AMIBA - […] Local Multiplier Effect […]
  54. Keeping Money Local: Shop Jamaica Plain | Jamaica Plain News - […] Alliance have shown that a minimum of nearly one-half of every dollar spent in small, local shops stays in…
  55. Give Yourself a Raise | occupycookbook - […] Multiplier Effect as talked about on the AMIBA website is a way to give yourself and your community a…
  56. Buy Products Made in Wisconsin! » Madison Teachers Inc. - […] This virtuous circle, in which middle class consumer spending fuels growth and prosperity, is the idea behind Buy Wisconsin.…
  57. Buy Products Made in Wisconsin! » Madison Teachers Inc. - […] This virtuous circle, in which middle class consumer spending fuels growth and prosperity, is the idea behind Buy Wisconsin.…
  58. Boston has a grocery market you’ll be jealous of, and it’s not owned by a giant corporation. | The Viral Beat - […] Did you know that for every $100 spent at a locally-owned business, $48 of that gets recycled right …?…
  59. How To Help Local Communities In 7 Ways - […] to American Independent Business Association, a whopping 48% of each purchase made in your local independent businesses  stays in…
  60. What’s the use of a local currency? – Birmingham Pound - […] 1https://www.amiba.net/resources/multiplier-effect/ […]
  61. Buying Local - Buy Local Michigan - […] services.  People that give back to their community and are there to help others. According to the American Independent…
  62. Billions of pounds of cheese are about to go to waste. Clearly America needs your help. - D1T - […] is all great for the cheese consumer and the local economy. But not so much for the large U.S.…
  63. Billions of pounds of cheese are about to go to waste. Clearly America needs your help. – ExtremeVirals.com - […] is all great for the cheese consumer and the local economy. But not so much for the large U.S.…
  64. Billions of pounds of cheese are about to go to waste. Clearly America needs your help. – Mostviral - […] is all great for the cheese consumer and the local economy. But not so much for the large U.S.…
  65. Billions of pounds of cheese are about to go to waste. Clearly America needs your help. | My Blog - […] is all great for the cheese consumer and the local economy. But not so much for the large U.S.…
  66. Billions of pounds of cheese are about to go to waste. Clearly America needs your help. – Daily News Trendz - […] is all great for the cheese consumer and the local economy. But not so much for the large U.S.…
  67. The Importance of Supporing Local BusinessesPromotion LA - […] to American Independent Business Alliance the Multiplier Effect is the idea that independent locally-owned businesses recirculate a far […]
  68. scottcaseysm - […] a consumer buys local, significantly more of that money stays in the community. In fact, one Chicago study found that for…
  69. Banks | occupycookbook - […] than chain competitors. This information coming from the American Independent Business Alliance: AMIBA multiplier. That means you return 2-3 times more…
  70. 5 Reasons to Shop Local – The Good News - […] to home. When you support locally owned businesses, nearly half (48%) of your purchase price is recirculated in the…
  71. Banks | Occupy Cookbook - […] than chain competitors. This information coming from the American Independent Business Alliance: AMIBA multiplier. That means you return 2-3 times more…
  72. Successful cities need more small business, and less big capital. | URBAN ReTHINK - […] shareholder’s pockets. This is something now called the multiplier effect of small business. One study in the US found…
  73. Why should you join a CSA? Week 4: Local produce means more benefits for you | Kellner Back Acre Garden - […] Photo credit: American Independent Business Alliance […]
  74. What are the benefits of supporting local products? - Manic - […] a customer buys locally produced products, more of that money stays in the community. A Chicago study found that for…
  75. Why care about local food? | Square Peg Food Farm - […] Choosing local food is a great way to support local families and individuals in your community and in turn,…
  76. Week 2 Secondary Post: Keep It Local – Blogging the Just City - […] Strengthens the Economy – Small businesses are more likely to put their money into more local businesses. “On average,…
  77. Can Shopping Local Save Detroit? - - […] This is a big small step.  The economic benefits of shopping locally cannot be over stated.  Supporting local businesses…
  78. Why Doesn’t Greg Gianforte Believe in Montana Tech Firms? | Intelligent Discontent - […] notes that decisions to purchase goods and services locally results in a significant multiplier effect, […]
  79. Last Minute Gifts - Being Frugal with Your Time and Energy - […] smaller locally owned stores, which are often much less crowded than big-box stores (it’s better for your town’s economy too).…
  80. The Chant : Why local businesses deserve your business - […] use. When a consumer buys local, significantly more of that money stays in the community. In fact, one Chicago…
  81. The Benefits of Buying Local | - […] How does one quantify how to Best impact their local economy by way of their spending habits?  To know…
  82. Shop Small, #drivesmall | RIDE Solutions - […] here and get spent again and again – about half of every dollar spent at a local business is…
  83. Shopping Small in Southie | the gift uncommon store - […] create a positive impact on local communities all year long. Studies show that when you shop local, 48% of…
  84. Frances, a Unique Boutique - two simple ideas - […] more information on the importance of supporting America’s small businesses please read The Multiplier Effect of Local Independent Businesses, published by…
  85. The Daily Dirt - Johnson's Backyard Garden - […] your dollars local this holiday season will not only support local businesses (who in turn, often keep their money local as…
  86. Shop Big on Small Business Saturday - Charlotte EAST - […] a you buy local, significantly more of that money stays in the community. In fact, one Chicago study found that…
  87. Why You Should Shop At Your Local Business - A Guest Blog - West Coast Tire - […] businesses also take the community seriously. They support the local community by returning 3x more to the local economy than…
  88. Retail is big in Macomb | Macomb Business - […] of these businesses are independently owned, which gives shoppers a chance to have a big impact. Recent research suggests…
  89. 6 Big Reasons Why You Should Shop Small Every Day | FiveStars Blog | Small Business Advice - […] more, according to Civic Economics, “on average, 48% of each purchase at local independent businesses is recirculated locally, […]
  90. Arts Business Institute | Shop Small - […] and cities. And shopping at small businesses fits perfect with that shop local trend. The American Independent Business Alliance…
  91. Does Small Business Saturday Really Matter? | Small Biz Viewpoints - […] not difficult to understand why studies have proven that nearly 48% of all money spent at local independent businesses…
  92. Shop Local. Build Community. - Shop Local Colorado Springs - […] many studies that show the economic impact of shopping local. In a recent article provided by the American Independent…
  93. Let your first thought about holiday shopping be: “Buy Local!” | South Central Grassroots Alliance - […] local money circulating in the local economy. Each dollar spent at a locally-owned independent businesses returns 3 times more…
  94. Local Car Service, Paisa, wins over residents with new AD campaign - neverending astoria - […] out how spending your money on local businesses actually does help your hyper local economy. “One Chicago study found…
  95. Boston has a grocery market you'll be jealous of, and it's not owned by a giant corporation. | Bullshit Guru - […] Did you know that for every $100 spent at a locally-owned business, $48 of that gets recycled right …?…

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This